Chapter 5 - Saint Cecilia Keeps Secrets

They reached Saint Cecilia before sunrise.
The church sat between two newer buildings in Lower Manhattan, its old stone facade blackened by decades of traffic. The front doors had been chained for nine years, but the Duca family still owned the narrow rectory beside it and the crypt beneath.
Nico entered first with two men he trusted enough to name without checking a list.
Anna followed Lorenzo through the side sacristy door.
Mrs. Bianca had stayed at the house with Sophie.
Anna had argued for twenty minutes before agreeing.
"If we're not back by eight," she had told Bianca, "take her to the place we discussed."
Lorenzo heard it.
"What place?"
"The place you don't need to know unless we're not back by eight."
He had almost objected.
Then he remembered Salvatore's tape.
Do not answer grief with speed.
He let it go.
Inside the church, dust lay across the pews like pale cloth. The stained-glass windows were black with pre-dawn darkness.
Anna walked directly to the sacristy.
"Gabriel said the records cabinet was behind a panel with a cracked brass cross."
They found it within three minutes.
A narrow panel opened behind an old vestment cupboard.
Inside was an iron box no larger than a briefcase.
Anna took the key from her neck.
Her hand shook.
Lorenzo covered it with his.
She looked at him.
"If this opens, everything changes."
"Everything already changed."
She inserted the key.
The lock turned.
Inside were six ledgers wrapped in oilcloth, three envelopes, and a manila folder marked with Salvatore's handwriting.
PIER 47.
Nico exhaled.
"Jesus."
Lorenzo opened the first ledger.
Payments. Dates. Initials. Shipping routes. Cash distributions. Politicians. Detectives. Port inspectors.
One set of initials appeared again and again.
C.D.
Beside a payment dated two days before Salvatore's shooting was a coded reference Lorenzo recognized immediately.
MULBERRY EXIT - 11:40.
Carlo had paid fifty thousand dollars that week to a company that did not exist.
Another ledger contained a payment six years later.
G.D. - CONNECTICUT - WEATHER LOSS.
Anna stopped breathing.
Lorenzo's hand tightened around the page.
There was an invoice number beside it.
Nico took out his phone.
"I can trace that."
"Do it from a clean device," Lorenzo said.
Anna touched the letters G.D.
"He wrote my husband's death like a shipping expense."
The words were almost soundless.
Lorenzo closed the ledger.
"Not anymore."
She looked up.
"Do not promise me revenge."
He stared at her.
"I didn't."
"Good. I had six years to imagine Carlo dead. It never brought Gabriel back."
"What do you want?"
"I want everybody who called my father a traitor to know his name was clean. I want Sophie to know her father did not die drunk on a wet road. I want Carlo to live long enough to hear both truths said where he cannot erase them."
Lorenzo nodded once.
"Then that is what we do."
Nico opened the manila folder.
Inside was a photograph of Salvatore and Enzo standing beside a cargo container. Behind them, barely visible in a reflection on polished steel, stood Carlo with a man Lorenzo recognized as Detective Raymond Pell, the officer who had led the original investigation into Salvatore's murder.
The next page was a handwritten statement from Salvatore.
If anything happens to me, investigate Carlo Duca, Raymond Pell, and Harbor Union Account 7714.
It was signed and dated three weeks before the shooting.
Anna pressed both hands to her mouth.
Lorenzo stared at his father's signature.
"He knew."
"He suspected," Nico said.
"And said nothing to me."
Anna looked at him.
"Maybe he was trying to protect you."
Lorenzo gave a bitter laugh.
"Apparently it runs in the family."
A floorboard creaked in the church.
Nico's head came up.
Not one of their men.
Too far left.
He killed the flashlight.
Darkness swallowed the sacristy.
Then the first shot struck the iron box.
The sound inside the stone church was enormous.
Anna dropped.
Lorenzo pulled her behind the vestment cabinet as Nico fired twice toward the doorway.
A second bullet tore through old wood above them.
"Back passage!" Nico shouted.
"There isn't one," Anna said.
"There is now."
One of Nico's men kicked through a rotted panel behind the cabinet. Plaster collapsed into a narrow service corridor.
Lorenzo shoved the ledgers into the canvas evidence bag.
"Move!"
Anna crawled through first.
Nico followed backward, firing toward the sacristy.
Someone shouted from the nave.
"Carlo wants the woman alive!"
Lorenzo heard it.
So did Anna.
They ran.
The corridor descended into the old crypt. Stone niches lined both walls. Several bore Duca names.
Salvatore's empty tomb waited at the far end.
Anna stumbled near it.
Lorenzo caught her.
A shot cracked behind them.
Nico grunted.
"Nico!"
"Shoulder," he said through his teeth. "Keep moving."
They reached a maintenance door opening into the alley.
One of Lorenzo's cars screamed around the corner.
They got Nico inside first.
Anna climbed in after him.
Lorenzo was halfway through the door when a man stepped from behind a parked van and raised a gun.
Anna saw him.
"Lorenzo!"
She fired.
The shot went wide.
But the man flinched.
Lorenzo turned, fired once, and the attacker dropped his weapon, clutching his thigh.
They drove.
For four blocks nobody spoke except Nico, who was swearing steadily while Anna pressed gauze against his shoulder.
Then Lorenzo's phone rang.
Carlo.
He answered on speaker.
"You went to church without me," Carlo said.
Lorenzo looked at Anna.
"I didn't think you'd enjoy the sermon."
Carlo laughed softly.
"Did you find what Gabriel found?"
Anna's hand stopped on the gauze.
Lorenzo's voice turned cold.
"You had my brother killed."
"Your brother made choices."
"So did my father."
"And look where that got him."
The line went dead.
Nico stared at the phone.
"He just admitted enough to bury himself."
"Not legally," Anna said.
Lorenzo looked at the ledgers on the floor.
"Then we make him say more."
His other phone buzzed.
A message from Mrs. Bianca.
Two words.
HOUSE BREACHED.
Then another.
SOPHIE SAFE.
Lorenzo looked up.
"Turn around."
The driver did not ask why.
The drive back from Saint Cecilia became its own confession.
Nico was pale from blood loss but conscious. Anna kept pressure on his wound while Lorenzo sat opposite with the evidence bag between his shoes.
"You knew Gabriel was investigating?" Anna asked Nico.
Nico shook his head.
"I knew he was angry. That was not unusual."
"He never told you about me?"
"No."
"Then he trusted you less than I thought."
Nico accepted that without defense.
"Or he was protecting you from what I might be forced to tell Lorenzo."
Lorenzo looked at him.
"Would you have told me?"
"Six years ago? Immediately."
"And I would have told Carlo."
"Probably."
The word landed harder because Nico did not soften it.
Lorenzo looked down at the ledgers.
Every relationship in his life was being remeasured against the man he had been.
Anna noticed.
"You cannot prosecute yourself for every decision you might have made."
"You seem to be doing a respectable job of it."
"I prosecute the decisions you actually made. There are enough."
Nico laughed once, then winced.
"I like her."
"You are bleeding. Your judgment is compromised."
At the mansion, before anyone entered, Lorenzo ordered every member of household security lined up in the garage. He walked down the row himself.
Some men met his eyes. Some did not.
One had a fresh scrape on his knuckles and claimed it came from a gate latch. Another had received three calls from a blocked number during the Saint Cecilia attack.
Lorenzo removed both from duty without violence.
Anna watched from the doorway.
"You would have handled that differently once."
"Yesterday."
"I was being polite."
He looked at her.
"Don't start now."
May you like
For the first time, her smile reached her eyes.
Then they heard Sophie crying inside, and every trace of humor vanished.