Chapter 3 - The Woman Who Wanted My LifeSophia Reynolds had never been poor.
That was the first lie Claire uncovered.
For years, Sophia had described herself as a struggling teacher who worked hard to make ends meet.
She frequently mentioned her student loans.
She complained about rising rent.
She accepted expensive gifts from Alexander with theatrical embarrassment.
And whenever Claire offered to help with anything, Sophia insisted she didn't want to impose.
But the financial records Rebecca obtained through legitimate corporate disclosures told a different story.
Sophia owned a condominium in downtown Chicago.
She also held an interest in a private investment company.
And six months earlier, that company had received a substantial payment from an entity connected to Vincent Caruso.
Claire knew the name.
Every wife in Alexander's social circle knew it.
Vincent Caruso was a businessman whose family had competed with the Morettis for decades.
The rivalry wasn't merely financial.
Men had disappeared.
Businesses had burned.
A warehouse fire ten years earlier had killed three workers.
Nobody had ever proved who ordered it.
Claire stared at the paperwork spread across Rebecca's conference table.
"Why would Sophia be receiving money from Vincent Caruso?"
Rebecca adjusted her glasses.
"We don't know yet. There may be a legitimate explanation."
Claire shook her head.
"Sophia has been inside our home almost every night for two years."
Rebecca nodded.
"Which is why we need to proceed carefully."
Claire looked at the payment date.
February 14.
Valentine's Day.
She remembered that evening clearly.
Alexander had promised to take her to dinner.
She had bought a navy dress.
She had even arranged for Noah's nanny to stay late.
Then Sophia had called.
Ethan was supposedly having trouble with school applications and needed her urgently.
Alexander had driven Ethan to Sophia's apartment.
He hadn't returned until after midnight.
Claire had eaten dinner alone.
Now she wondered whether Ethan had needed anyone at all.
Rebecca slid another page across the table.
"There's something else."
It was a property record.
Sophia's investment company had negotiated an option to purchase a warehouse facility located near one of Bennett Harbor's most profitable terminals.
The option depended on a management change.
Claire looked up.
"If someone obtained my voting rights, could they authorize the sale?"
"Potentially, subject to corporate restrictions and approvals."
"And if Sophia controlled the votes?"
Rebecca didn't answer immediately.
Then she said, "She could have significant influence over the future of those assets."
Claire felt the familiar ache of betrayal.
For years, she had thought Sophia wanted Alexander.
Now it seemed possible that Alexander was only part of the prize.
At the mansion, Alexander stood alone in the kitchen.
Claire had left a handwritten list taped inside one cabinet.
NOAH'S FAVORITES
Monday: chicken soup.
Tuesday: pasta with little meatballs.
Wednesday: salmon if he's in the mood.
No strawberries after dinner if his stomach is upset.
Alexander ran a finger over the handwriting.
He remembered laughing once when Claire wrote lists like this.
"You run this house like a military operation," he'd told her.
She had smiled.
"Someone has to remember everything."
He hadn't understood that she'd been telling him how exhausted she was.
A voice interrupted him.
"Mr. Moretti?"
It was Rosa, the longtime housekeeper.
She had worked for the family since before Ethan was born.
"Yes?"
"May I speak freely?"
Alexander turned.
Rosa looked nervous.
"Always."
She took a breath.
"Mrs. Moretti was very unhappy."
Alexander closed his eyes.
"I know."
"No, sir. I don't think you do."
He looked at her.
Rosa continued.
"For almost a year, she stopped eating breakfast with the family."
"She was busy."
"She sat in the pantry."
Alexander frowned.
"What?"
"Sometimes she would make everyone breakfast and then sit in the pantry with coffee."
"Why?"
Rosa's eyes filled.
"Because Mr. Ethan would ask Miss Reynolds to sit beside him, and you would tell Mrs. Moretti to make room."
Alexander stared.
He remembered those mornings.
Sophia at the table.
Ethan laughing.
Claire standing with a plate.
Alexander motioning toward the empty seat near the kitchen.
He'd considered it harmless.
He hadn't noticed that eventually Claire stopped coming.
Rosa wiped her hands on her apron.
"Mrs. Moretti never complained to me. But she cried sometimes."
The words struck him harder than he expected.
"Why didn't you tell me?"
Rosa looked at him sadly.
"She was your wife, sir."
Alexander had no response.
Then Rosa added something unexpected.
"And there's something about Miss Reynolds you should know."
His attention sharpened.
"What?"
"Last month, I found her in Mrs. Moretti's study."
Alexander frowned.
"Doing what?"
"Looking through the filing cabinet."
"Did she explain?"
"She said she was searching for Noah's school enrollment papers."
Alexander went still.
"Noah is three."
"Yes, sir."
Rosa lowered her voice.
"And the cabinet she was searching was the one containing Mrs. Bennett's old documents."
Claire's mother's documents.
Alexander felt his blood run cold.
Ethan was sitting in his car outside Sophia's condominium when Alexander called him.
"Where are you?"
"With Sophia."
"Have you gone inside?"
"Not yet."
"Come home."
Ethan frowned.
"Why?"
"Because I said so."
"Dad, I'm eighteen."
Alexander gripped the phone.
"Then start acting like it."
Ethan went silent.
Alexander immediately regretted his tone.
He was trying to repair his family.
He couldn't continue using anger as his only language.
"Ethan," he said more quietly, "I need you home. There are things we have to discuss."
"About Mom?"
"Yes."
Ethan hesitated.
"Can I ask you something?"
"Of course."
"Did you ever love her?"
Alexander closed his eyes.
The question was so simple.
And so devastating.
"Yes."
"Then why did you let Sophia treat her like that?"
Alexander leaned against the desk.
He had no honest answer that made him look good.
"Because I was selfish," he said.
"And I didn't want to see what was happening."
Ethan breathed shakily.
"Mom used to wait up for me."
Alexander listened.
"Even when I told her not to."
"I know."
"Last winter I had a bad night. I called Sophia because I was embarrassed to tell Mom I'd failed a test."
Alexander frowned.
"What happened?"
"Sophia told me Mom wouldn't understand. She said Mom only cared about making the family look perfect."
"Did you believe her?"
"Yeah."
Ethan's voice cracked.
"But when I came home, Mom had left my favorite soup on the stove. She'd written a note saying she knew I was having a hard week and didn't have to explain anything until I was ready."
Alexander closed his eyes.
"She did things like that all the time."
"I know."
Ethan began crying.
"I just didn't notice anymore."
Alexander pressed his forehead against the window.
"Come home, son."
This time, Ethan didn't argue.
The following afternoon, Claire watched Noah wave at his father through a video screen.
"Daddy!"
Alexander's face changed completely.
For a moment, the powerful man Claire had married disappeared.
He looked like an ordinary father who missed his little boy.
"Hey, buddy."
Noah pressed his toy truck against the camera.
"Look!"
Alexander smiled.
"That's a great truck."
"It's red!"
"I can see that."
"Mommy bought it!"
Alexander's smile faltered.
Claire stayed off camera.
Her attorney was present on the call, and Alexander had agreed not to discuss their marriage in front of Noah.
For fifteen minutes, father and son talked about trucks, dinosaurs, and a strange bird Noah had seen outside the cottage.
Then Noah asked, "Daddy, why didn't you come with us?"
Alexander stopped smiling.
Claire held her breath.
He could have lied.
He could have blamed her.
He could have said Daddy had too much work.
Instead, he looked into the camera.
"Because Daddy made some bad choices."
Noah frowned.
"Like when I drew on the wall?"
Alexander gave a small, broken laugh.
"Yes, buddy. But much bigger."
"Did Mommy put you in timeout?"
Alexander lowered his head.
"Something like that."
Claire covered her mouth.
Noah nodded wisely.
"You have to say sorry."
Alexander looked toward the edge of the screen.
"I know."
Claire turned away before he could see her crying.
That evening, Sophia went to Vincent Caruso's private office.
The office occupied the top floor of a luxury building overlooking the Chicago River.
Vincent was sixty-two, silver-haired, impeccably dressed, and known for smiling when delivering threats.
Sophia stood before his desk.
"We have a problem."
Vincent didn't look up from his drink.
"Alexander suspects something?"
"He's asking about Bennett Harbor."
Vincent's expression darkened.
"How much does he know?"
"I don't know."
"Then find out."
Sophia folded her arms.
"Claire has lawyers."
"Claire has always had lawyers. What she didn't have was knowledge."
"She knows now."
Vincent set down his glass.
"Then your time is running out."
Sophia looked toward the windows.
"I did everything you asked."
Vincent smiled without warmth.
"You were supposed to keep the wife distracted and the husband dependent."
"I did."
"You were supposed to obtain her signature."
"I tried."
"And you failed."
Sophia's cheeks reddened.
"Alexander wouldn't let me near the final documents."
Vincent leaned forward.
"Then perhaps you should have worked harder."
Sophia stared at him.
"I gave you two years of my life."
Vincent's voice grew cold.
"And I gave you enough money to buy your little apartment twice."
She stepped closer.
"You promised that once the transfer was complete, I'd have my own company."
"Once it was complete."
Sophia's hands curled into fists.
Vincent continued.
"Now Claire Bennett has awakened, and Alexander Moretti is beginning to ask questions. That makes you a liability."
For the first time, real fear appeared in Sophia's eyes.
"What are you saying?"
Vincent stood.
"I'm saying you'd better give me something useful."
Sophia hesitated.
Then whispered, "I know where Claire's son is."
Vincent went still.
He studied her.
Then smiled slowly.
"Now," he said, "that's interesting."
Claire was reading Noah a bedtime story when her phone lit up.
A message from an unfamiliar number.
There was no text.
Only a photograph.
She opened it.
And her heart stopped.
The picture showed the front of the cottage.
The small white porch.
The flower boxes.
The red bicycle leaning beside the fence.
Then a second photograph arrived.
Noah at the playground that afternoon.
His blue jacket.
His little red shoes.
Claire shot to her feet.
A third message appeared.
Your mother should have minded her own business.
Claire's hands shook so badly she nearly dropped the phone.
She called her attorney first.
Then the local police.
Then Rebecca.
Only after Noah was safely beside her and officers had been dispatched did she look at the final message.
It contained seven words.
Sign the papers, or lose something precious.
Claire stared toward her sleeping son.
May you like
And understood that leaving Alexander had not ended the danger.
It had only revealed who had been waiting for her to become vulnerable.
Related Stories
