Chapter 8 - The Deposition That Shattered the Fairytale

By the time the formal deposition arrived three weeks later, the legal landscape had shifted from a skirmish into an absolute rout.
Gregory Vance had officially withdrawn as Daniel’s counsel under threat of immediate disbarment. Daniel had been forced to retain a court-appointed public referral attorney named Harold Jenkins—a tired, overworked man in a rumpled brown corduroy jacket who looked like he had drawn the short straw in a public defender lottery.
The deposition took place in the grand deposition suite of Chen & Associates.
Judge Hetherington had ordered Daniel to appear personally to respond to the allegations of marital dissipation, corporate fraud, and to defend his claim for residential equity.
Daniel sat at the center of the table.
He had lost at least fifteen pounds in three weeks. His bespoke suit looked like it belonged to an older, larger brother. His hair was unwashed, his cheeks were hollow, and his hands trembled slightly as he poured water from a glass pitcher, splashing several drops onto the polished mahogany.
Mara Chen sat opposite him, calm, rested, and armed with four leather-bound volumes of verified financial records.
“State your full legal name for the record,” Mara began, nodding to the videographer in the corner.
“Daniel Thomas Lawson,” he muttered, looking down at his knuckles.
“Mr. Lawson, in your initial counter-petition for dissolution of marriage, filed under signature of your previous counsel on April 12th, you asserted an equitable claim of three hundred and six thousand dollars against the real property located at 1148 Bridlewood Way. Is that correct?”
Harold Jenkins, Daniel’s new attorney, sighed softly and nudged Daniel’s shoulder.
“Yes,” Daniel whispered.
“And the basis of that claim,” Mara continued, “was that you contributed substantial marital labor and marital capital toward the appreciation and maintenance of that home over your eight years of cohabitation. Is that correct?”
“Yes.”
Mara opened Volume One.
“Mr. Lawson, I hand you Exhibit 14. This is an itemized breakdown of your personal income tax returns from 2016 through 2023. Over that eight-year period, what was your average reported adjusted gross income?”
Daniel stared at the paper. His throat bobbed. He didn't answer.
“Mr. Lawson, please read the highlighted figure on page four,” Mara commanded, her voice firm and inescapable.
“Twenty-four thousand, two hundred dollars,” Daniel choked out.
“Twenty-four thousand, two hundred dollars annually,” Mara repeated for the court reporter. “During that same eight-year period, what was my client, Rebecca Cole’s, average reported adjusted gross income?”
Daniel closed his eyes. “Four hundred and eighty thousand dollars.”
“Four hundred and eighty thousand dollars,” Mara said. “Now let us look at the maintenance expenses for 1148 Bridlewood Way over that period. Total property taxes paid: one hundred and twelve thousand dollars. Total roof replacement: thirty-eight thousand dollars. Total HVAC geothermal installation: forty-four thousand dollars. Total landscaping and structural upkeep: ninety-six thousand dollars.”
Mara leaned forward, her silver glasses catching the light.
“Mr. Lawson, your total pre-tax earnings over the entire eight years of marriage amounted to less than one hundred and ninety-four thousand dollars. The basic physical maintenance of the Bridlewood property exceeded two hundred and ninety thousand dollars. Mathematically speaking, Mr. Lawson, you didn't contribute to the appreciation of that home; you were an unfunded dependent residing inside it.”
Harold Jenkins leaned over, whispered something in Daniel’s ear, and shook his head.
“Now,” Mara continued, not giving him a second to breathe. “Let us turn to Volume Two: The dissipation.”
She laid out fifty-four separate checks and wire receipts.
“Between June of last year and March of this year, you transferred one hundred and forty-two thousand, five hundred dollars into DLE Holdings. You also transferred sixty thousand dollars from Midwest Surgical Logistics—partnership capital belonging to your business partner, Mark Henderson—into that same account. And where did those funds go, Daniel?”
Mara began sliding photographs across the table.
“A nose job for Emily Vance: fifteen thousand dollars.”
*Slide.*
“Cheek contouring for Emily Vance: fifteen thousand dollars.”
*Slide.*
“Seven months of luxury apartment rent at Wellington Court: twelve thousand, nine hundred and fifty dollars.”
*Slide.*
“A Cartier Love bracelet found in Emily Vance’s possession: seven thousand, four hundred dollars.”
*Slide.*
“And a forty-five-thousand-dollar illegal legal retainer paid to her brother.”
Mara stacked the photographs into a neat, terrifying pile right in front of Daniel’s trembling hands.
“Mr. Lawson, did you inform your wife that you were using her executive consulting revenue to finance the aesthetic surgery and high-rise living of your twenty-six-year-old mistress?”
Daniel’s face broke. A jagged, ugly sob escaped his chest. He buried his face in his hands, his shoulders heaving violently.
“No,” he wept into his palms. “No... I didn't.”
“And why did you do it, Daniel?” Mara asked, her voice dropping into a cold, clinical curiosity. “Why did you tell my client that Emily loved you for ‘who you were at your core,’ when every single milestone of that relationship was purchased with my client’s corporate sweat?”
Daniel couldn't speak. He wept openly, the tears dripping through his fingers onto the certified transcripts of his own financial deceit.
Harold Jenkins tapped the table. “Counsel, we need a five-minute recess. My client is... emotionally incapacitated.”
“Take ten minutes, Mr. Jenkins,” Mara said, closing her folder. “When we return, we will discuss the criminal referral for the sixty thousand dollars stolen from Midwest Surgical Logistics.”
During the recess, Daniel walked out into the corridor. I was standing near the floor-to-ceiling windows, looking down at the street below.
He approached me slowly, his steps dragging, his eyes bloodshot, his face ruined. Harold Jenkins stood ten yards away, deliberately looking at his phone, offering no protection.
“Rebecca,” Daniel whispered, his voice completely broken. “Please. Stop this. They’re going to put me in prison. Mark filed a police report this morning for the sixty thousand dollars. Centier Bank has called in the commercial notes. I have nothing left. I am sleeping on an air mattress in my old storage unit.”
I turned to look at him.
There was no anger left in me. There was no hatred. There was only the profound, peaceful indifference of an adult who had finally walked away from a destructive, spoiled child.
“Where is Emily, Daniel?” I asked gently. “Why isn't she here holding your hand? She loved you for your unadorned soul, didn't she?”
Daniel’s chin trembled. A fresh tear carved a path through the dust on his cheek.
“She packed her bags three nights ago,” he whispered, his voice cracking into pieces. “She told me... she told me I was the biggest mistake of her life. She took the YSL bag, she took the jewelry, and she went back to her parents’ house in Kokomo. She won't even answer my texts.”
I nodded slowly. “Of course she did, Daniel. A parasite doesn't stay on a host once the heart stops beating.”
“Can you help me?” he begged, reaching out a hand, his fingers curling in a pathetic, pleading gesture. “Just pay Mark back the sixty thousand. Just withdraw the fraud complaint so I don't go to jail. For eight years, Rebecca. For the eight years we had together. Please.”
I looked at him, remembering the man who had stood in my kitchen thirty days earlier, wearing my watch, looking down his nose at me, telling me that real love wasn't something I could buy with an executive salary.
“Daniel,” I said softly, looking him dead in his weeping eyes. “I am just a cold, transactional woman. And sixty thousand dollars... simply isn't a good investment.”
May you like
I turned on my heel, walked back into the deposition suite, and let the heavy glass doors close between us.
***