Chapter 3 - The Empty Chair at the Mafia Boss's Christmas TableFor a moment, nobody moved.
Snow settled on Gabriel's shoulders as he held the phone.
I could hear laughter from inside the house.
Somebody was singing badly.
A child squealed.
And I stood on the front steps of a stranger's home, wondering whether accepting one Christmas invitation had just dragged me into something I couldn't escape.
"Who filed the report?" Nico asked.
"Anonymous submission to Boston Police," Gabriel replied. "A contact notified our attorney that a complaint naming you had been received. No one has asked to interview either of you yet."
"What exactly does it say?"
Gabriel scrolled.
"That Miss Bennett removed financial records after being confronted over stolen inventory, and that you assisted her."
I felt sick.
"That's not what happened."
Nico turned toward me.
"I know."
"No, you don't understand. Those are photographs of my own notes. I didn't take company invoices or anything from their computer."
"Clara."
His voice was calm.
"Look at me."
I did.
"An accusation isn't proof."
"But people believe accusations."
Something passed through his eyes.
"I know that better than most."
He looked at Gabriel.
"Forward the report details to counsel. Preserve the original camera recordings from the property. And make sure Evelyn Price has everything she needs."
Gabriel nodded.
"Already contacting her office."
I stared at him.
"Should I go home?"
Nico answered immediately.
"Only if you want to."
"But this could cause trouble."
"Clara, trouble found this house long before you did."
He gestured toward the front door.
"Come meet my family."
I hesitated.
Then I followed him inside.
The warmth hit me first.
Not just from the old radiators or the enormous fireplace glowing in the living room.
From the noise.
Music played somewhere downstairs. The house smelled of roasted garlic, tomato sauce, fresh bread, and cinnamon.
Coats hung from every available hook.
Children's boots crowded the entryway.
A golden retriever wearing a crooked red bow rushed toward us.
"Nico!"
A woman's voice thundered from the kitchen.
"Tell me you didn't bring another one of those ridiculous expensive wines."
Nico closed his eyes.
"Good evening to you, too, Aunt Rosa."
A short woman with silver hair and a red apron appeared around the corner.
She was probably seventy, although her posture suggested she had no intention of acknowledging her age.
She wiped her hands on a dish towel.
Then she saw me.
Her expression transformed.
"Oh!"
I froze.
Nico touched the small of my back briefly.
"Aunt Rosa, this is Clara Bennett."
Rosa looked at me.
Then at Nico.
Then at me again.
"Clara?"
"Yes, ma'am."
She marched toward me.
Before I could prepare myself, she wrapped both arms around me.
"Welcome, sweetheart."
I stopped breathing.
She smelled like vanilla and rosemary.
"Thank you," I whispered.
"Have you eaten?"
"Not really."
"Of course you haven't."
She turned toward Nico.
"Look at her. It's almost seven o'clock."
"I've been with her for twenty minutes, Rosa."
"And apparently you spent all twenty doing absolutely nothing useful."
Behind me, Gabriel coughed.
Nico looked toward the ceiling as though seeking divine patience.
Rosa took my coat.
"Come on. Everybody's in the dining room. And don't let my nephew intimidate you. He was afraid of chickens until he was twelve."
I turned.
Nico's expression was murderous.
I smiled.
"Chickens?"
"Clara."
"Oh, I'm definitely going to need that story."
Rosa laughed triumphantly.
And just like that, the ice inside my chest began to melt.
There were twenty-six people around the dining room and adjoining kitchen.
Not the intimidating assembly of criminals I'd imagined.
There were firefighters.
A retired dockworker.
A high school teacher.
Two young nurses.
Several children.
A woman who owned a flower shop.
An elderly man who had apparently been arguing with Rosa about the Red Sox since 1987.
Some were relatives.
Others were friends.
Several had worked for Nico's family for decades.
And everyone seemed to have an opinion about his personal life.
A young woman with dark curls approached me while I was helping Rosa carry bread.
"I'm Mia."
She held out her hand.
"Nico's niece."
"Clara."
Her eyes sparkled.
"You're the pastry chef."
I blinked.
"You know?"
"My uncle once drove across Boston during a thunderstorm because your bakery was closing early."
From across the room, Nico said, "Mia."
She grinned.
"What? It's true."
"You told me the drive was for business," Gabriel added.
"It was."
Mia leaned toward me.
"He's very committed to business involving plum pastries."
I laughed.
Nico looked as though he was considering leaving his own Christmas party.
Mia was twenty, a college student home for winter break, and completely unimpressed by her uncle's reputation.
Within ten minutes, she had told me about his terrible childhood haircut, his inability to sing, and the time he tried to bake a birthday cake and produced something she described as "a roofing material."
By the time dinner was served, my face hurt from smiling.
Then Rosa brought me to the table.
A beautiful old walnut table.
White candles.
Evergreen branches.
Silverware polished until it gleamed.
And one empty chair beside Nico.
A place setting waited in front of it.
I stopped.
"Oh."
Rosa noticed.
"What?"
"Nothing. I just—"
I swallowed.
"You already set a place."
"Of course."
"But you didn't know I was coming."
Rosa studied my face.
Then she said something softly enough that only I could hear.
"In this house, we set extra places. You never know who might need one."
My eyes burned.
She squeezed my hand.
"Sit down, honey."
I looked at the chair.
For twenty-eight years, I'd been told where to stand.
Which photographs to avoid.
How much food I should put on my plate.
How to behave so nobody would be embarrassed.
And here was a woman who barely knew me, pulling out a chair as if I had always belonged.
I sat down.
Nico took the seat beside me.
He noticed the tears I was trying to hide.
"Everything okay?"
I nodded too quickly.
He glanced toward Rosa.
Then back at me.
"She didn't tell you about the chickens, did she?"
I laughed through the tears.
"Not yet."
"Then the evening can still be saved."
Dinner lasted almost three hours.
Nobody counted what I ate.
Nobody commented on my body.
Nobody suggested I should skip dessert.
In fact, when I reached for a small portion of lasagna, Rosa placed an enormous serving on my plate and declared that anybody who left her table hungry was insulting her ancestors.
Mia asked about my work.
A firefighter named Sean wanted to know whether sourdough starter really needed feeding every day.
An older woman named Denise told me she'd always dreamed of opening a bakery but had ended up running a hardware store with her husband.
People listened when I spoke.
They didn't interrupt.
They didn't exchange amused looks.
I wasn't the punch line of somebody else's family story.
I was simply Clara.
After dinner, Rosa insisted that everyone share one thing they were grateful for.
When it was my turn, I froze.
Twenty-five faces turned toward me.
My throat tightened.
"I don't really know what to say."
"Then say what's true," Rosa replied.
I looked around.
At the candles.
At Mia smiling encouragement.
At Gabriel pretending not to watch the doorway while helping an elderly guest cut his dessert.
And finally at Nico.
He was looking at me with an expression I couldn't name.
"I was supposed to spend Christmas alone," I said.
The room grew quiet.
"My family changed plans without telling me. And yesterday, I lost my job."
Rosa's face softened.
I continued before I lost my nerve.
"I spent a lot of today wondering whether I had done something wrong. Something that made me difficult to love."
My hands tightened around my napkin.
"But tonight, everybody has been so kind to me, and nobody even knew I was coming."
I took a shaky breath.
"So I guess I'm grateful that an empty chair can be something good."
Nobody spoke for a moment.
Then Rosa stood.
She walked around the table and kissed the top of my head.
"Oh, sweetheart."
I broke.
The tears came without warning.
Not dramatic, pretty tears.
Real ones.
The kind that made my chest hurt and my face crumple.
I tried to apologize.
Rosa wouldn't let me.
"Not one apology," she said firmly. "Not for crying. Not in my house."
Across the table, Mia wiped her own eyes.
Somebody passed me a tissue.
Then Sean raised his glass.
"To extra chairs."
"To extra chairs," everyone repeated.
Nico didn't raise his glass immediately.
He was watching me.
And when our eyes met, he said quietly, "I'm glad you came."
The words settled somewhere deep inside me.
For the first time that Christmas, I believed somebody meant them.
After dinner, I escaped to the back porch for air.
Snow covered the small garden.
The city sounded impossibly peaceful.
I wrapped my arms around myself and watched flakes gather along the railing.
The door opened.
Nico stepped outside carrying my coat.
"Rosa will kill me if you catch pneumonia."
I smiled.
"She seems capable of it."
He draped the coat over my shoulders.
For a moment, we stood together in silence.
Then I said, "Your family is wonderful."
"They have their moments."
"Rosa loves you."
He smiled faintly.
"She's spent forty years making sure I never forget it."
I looked toward the windows.
"That must be nice."
He didn't answer immediately.
Then he said, "It is."
The honesty made me turn toward him.
He leaned against the railing, looking out at the garden.
"She raised Marco and me after my mother died."
"Your brother?"
He nodded.
"Mia's father."
I remembered the article.
"The warehouse fire."
His jaw tightened.
"Yes."
"And Anna was there too."
"Yes."
I hesitated.
"Can I ask something?"
"You can ask."
"Why were they in the warehouse?"
He watched the falling snow.
"Anna was helping an employee collect records. Marco went to get her when the fire started."
"Why would anyone set it on fire?"
"Because those records contained things someone wanted destroyed."
My stomach tightened.
"Did you know what was in them?"
"Some of it."
He turned toward me.
"The business I inherited wasn't clean, Clara. My father made money through legitimate freight contracts, but he also collected payments from people who didn't have a choice. When he died, Marco and I inherited both sides."
I was silent.
"I tried to separate them," Nico continued. "Marco wanted to move faster. Anna believed the only way to stop certain people was to expose what they'd been doing."
"And someone killed them."
"I believe so."
He stared into the darkness.
"Afterward, I wanted revenge more than I wanted justice."
"What did you do?"
His answer came slowly.
"I had men hurt people I believed were responsible. One of them was innocent of the fire."
I felt cold.
He looked at me.
"I'm not telling you this because I want sympathy. I'm telling you because you should know what kind of man you're standing beside."
I swallowed.
"Did the innocent man survive?"
"Yes. He was badly injured. I later learned he had nothing to do with the fire."
"Did you apologize?"
"Yes."
"Did it fix anything?"
"No."
I appreciated that answer more than I wanted to.
He didn't excuse himself.
Didn't talk about honor or necessary violence.
Didn't pretend that regret erased harm.
"Why are you telling me?"
"Because there's a good chance someone will tell you a version designed to frighten you. I'd rather you hear the truth from me."
I looked at his hands.
Large hands.
A faint scar across one knuckle.
Hands that had opened a car door for me.
Hands that had once ordered something terrible.
"Are you trying to become someone different?" I asked.
He took a long breath.
"I've spent years changing how my businesses operate and removing people who still rely on coercion. But change doesn't erase what I did."
"No."
I looked up.
"It doesn't."
He didn't flinch.
And somehow, his willingness to accept that answer made the space between us feel safer.
Then he asked, "Are you frightened of me?"
I considered lying.
Instead, I shook my head.
"I'm frightened of what I don't know."
"Fair."
"And I'm frightened that I might start depending on somebody who could disappear."
His expression changed.
"That isn't something I can ask you to stop feeling."
"No."
The porch door opened.
Mia poked her head out.
"Uncle Nico, your attorney is here."
Nico straightened.
"Now?"
Mia's smile vanished.
"She says it's important."
Evelyn Price stood in Rosa's study beside another attorney, a man named Andrew Callahan who represented Vale Harbor Holdings.
She had come because the allegations against me had escalated.
Someone had sent a packet of documents to a local business reporter.
I stared at the pages on the desk.
A photograph of my employee ID.
An accusation that I had stolen luxury ingredients.
A statement claiming Nico had pressured Winter & Rye to conceal the theft.
And a photocopy of what appeared to be a supplier invoice.
I leaned closer.
"That's not right."
Evelyn looked at me.
"What?"
I pointed to the document.
"The invoice says thirty cases of imported chocolate were delivered December twelfth."
"Yes."
"But that wasn't a chocolate delivery. It was supposed to be pastry flour."
Andrew frowned.
"Are you certain?"
I nodded.
"The item description changed."
Evelyn opened the notebook photographs on her tablet.
We compared the records.
The original purchase order listed flour.
The document sent to the reporter listed chocolate.
Same invoice number.
Same date.
Same price.
Different product.
Nico leaned forward.
"What does that mean?"
I looked at him.
"Somebody changed the invoice after it was created."
Evelyn studied the page.
"That could matter."
I pointed again.
"And that's not the supplier's normal address."
Andrew read it aloud.
"North Quay Provisioning. Pier Seventeen, Boston."
Nico went completely still.
Gabriel, standing near the door, looked up sharply.
"What?" I asked.
Nobody answered.
I looked at Nico.
"Nico?"
His eyes were fixed on the page.
When he finally spoke, his voice was almost unrecognizable.
"Pier Seventeen burned eleven years ago."
I stopped breathing.
May you like
He continued.
"That's the warehouse where Anna and Marco died."
Related Stories
