Chapter 3 - Olivia Hart Had Never Wanted to Be the Other Woman Forever

Richard did not go home after leaving the hospital.
He drove directly to Bennett Global's Manhattan headquarters, a forty-eight-story glass tower overlooking Park Avenue. The building had been his obsession since he was thirty-two, when he had borrowed money from three investors and transformed a struggling logistics firm into an international holding company.
He had spent a decade building an empire that appeared invulnerable.
Now, for the first time, he entered his own office feeling as though the floor might give way beneath him.
His executive assistant, Natalie Brooks, stood as he approached.
"Mr. Bennett, your three o'clock meeting is waiting."
"Cancel it."
"Your four o'clock with the London team—"
"Cancel everything."
Natalie paused.
"Is there something I should know?"
Richard looked at her.
"No."
She lowered her eyes.
He had always liked Natalie because she was efficient, discreet, and never asked questions that were not strictly necessary. But as he walked into his office, he noticed that she had stopped looking at him with her usual confidence.
Perhaps the news had already spread.
Perhaps everyone knew about the missed hospital calls.
Perhaps he was the last person in Manhattan to understand the damage he had done.
He closed the door and called Olivia.
She answered on the second ring.
"Finally. I've been trying to reach you."
Richard closed his eyes.
"Olivia, I need to talk to you."
"About the London acquisition? I sent you the revised figures."
"Not about London."
A pause.
"Then what?"
"Maya filed for divorce."
Silence.
Then Olivia exhaled.
"Oh."
Richard waited for concern, surprise, perhaps even a question about Maya's health.
Instead, Olivia asked, "Does that mean you're finally going to tell everyone about us?"
He opened his eyes.
"My wife nearly died."
"I know she had complications."
"She was in emergency surgery."
"I'm sorry, Richard, but what do you want me to say?"
He stared at the skyline.
"Something that suggests you understand the seriousness of what happened."
Olivia's voice cooled.
"I understand that you are upset. But we have been talking about your marriage for almost a year. You told me it was over emotionally long before the babies were conceived."
Richard felt the first stirrings of anger.
"I never said it was over."
"You said you were staying because of appearances."
"I said things were complicated."
"You said Maya and you barely spoke. You said the pregnancy had made everything more difficult. You said you would make a decision once the acquisition closed."
He remembered those conversations.
He remembered the promises he had made in hotel rooms and private cars, always using the future tense because it allowed him to avoid acting in the present.
"That doesn't mean I wanted her to be hurt."
Olivia laughed softly.
"No one wants to be the villain, Richard. That doesn't mean you aren't one."
He was stunned by the bluntness of the remark.
"You were at your birthday party when the hospital called me."
"And you stayed."
"You encouraged me to ignore the calls."
"I told you not to let the evening be ruined by business. I had no idea your wife was bleeding to death."
"You knew the calls were from the hospital."
"I assumed they would reach you if it was an emergency."
Richard said nothing.
Olivia continued.
"You made your choice. Don't turn around and blame me because you regret it now."
For the first time, he wondered whether Olivia had ever understood him at all.
Then she asked the question that revealed more than anything else she could have said.
"Are you still going to pay for the apartment?"
Richard stared at his phone.
"What?"
"The apartment. You said you would cover it through the end of the year."
He had arranged a luxury apartment for Olivia near Central Park, ostensibly because she needed a place to stay during late-night work sessions. He had paid the deposit through a consulting entity and covered the rent from a discretionary corporate account.
He had never told Maya.
"Now is not the time to discuss that."
"When will be the time?"
"Olivia, my wife has just filed for divorce."
"Exactly. Which means things are changing. I need to know where I stand."
Richard felt a coldness spread through him.
"You stand where you have always stood. This relationship was never supposed to become a public spectacle."
Olivia's voice sharpened.
"You told me you would stop hiding me."
"I told you I would deal with my marriage."
"You said that six months ago."
"And I am dealing with it now."
"No, Richard. Your wife dealt with it. She left. You are only reacting because you no longer control the situation."
He ended the call.
For several seconds, he stood perfectly still.
Then he walked to his desk and opened the drawer where he kept a bottle of expensive whiskey.
He poured a glass.
He did not drink it.
Instead, he stared at the amber liquid and thought about the photograph of Olivia at the birthday party.
He had believed she was different from Maya.
Maya had wanted him to attend appointments, answer calls, and remember promises.
Olivia had wanted him to take her to Paris, buy her jewelry, and assure her that she would eventually become more than a secret.
Both women had asked him to show up.
He had treated their requests as competing obligations rather than as evidence that he had built a life around avoiding difficult choices.
A knock sounded at the door.
Natalie entered carrying a folder.
"I'm sorry to interrupt, but the finance director has requested your approval for a payment connected to the European acquisition."
"Leave it."
She placed the folder on his desk, then hesitated.
"There's another matter."
Richard looked up.
"What?"
"The hospital called the office yesterday. They asked us to confirm the emergency contact information for Mrs. Bennett's admission."
His face tightened.
"Who took the call?"
"I did."
"And?"
"I told them you were traveling. They said they had attempted to contact you directly."
Richard stared at her.
"Did they say anything else?"
Natalie seemed uncomfortable.
"They asked whether there was another family contact. I gave them Mrs. Eleanor Bennett's number."
He sat back.
"Thank you."
Natalie did not leave.
"Mr. Bennett, may I say something?"
He almost told her no.
Instead, he gestured impatiently.
"Go ahead."
"I've worked here for six years. I've watched you cancel meetings for investors, fly across the country for clients, and rearrange your schedule when a deal was at risk."
Richard's expression hardened.
"This is not an appropriate conversation."
"I know."
She swallowed.
"But I also watched Mrs. Bennett come here last winter with a medical report because she wanted you to attend an appointment with her. You told her you had a call. She waited in the reception area for forty minutes before leaving alone."
He remembered that day.
Maya had worn a cream coat and carried a folder. He had been preparing for a presentation to the board.
He had assumed she understood.
Natalie continued.
"I don't know what happened at the hospital. I don't know what your marriage is like behind closed doors. But I know she tried to reach you through this office, too."
Richard looked away.
"That's enough."
Natalie nodded.
"I'm sorry."
She left the folder and walked out.
Richard sat alone until the light outside his windows began to fade.
Then he opened the financial records for the European acquisition.
He was not sure why.
Perhaps he needed to look at something that still made sense.
The transaction involved the purchase of a regional logistics network with warehouses across France, Germany, and the Netherlands. Olivia had coordinated much of the communication, arranging introductions and preparing investor materials.
The deal was valuable.
It was also unusually complicated.
Richard had noticed discrepancies in the preliminary cost reports, but Olivia had assured him that the numbers were being reconciled by the finance team.
He opened the latest report.
A series of consulting payments appeared in the appendix.
Several had been routed through a company called Hart Strategic Advisory.
He frowned.
Olivia had mentioned the firm as a partner on the acquisition. Richard had assumed it was a legitimate subcontractor.
He examined the payment dates.
Some had been approved before the acquisition negotiations began.
Others had been processed through accounts that were not ordinarily used for external consultants.
He called the finance director.
"Send me every invoice connected to Hart Strategic Advisory."
"All of them?"
"Every invoice. Every approval. Every supporting document."
The director hesitated.
"Is there a problem?"
"I don't know yet."
After the call, Richard opened his private email account and searched for Olivia's name.
He found dozens of messages.
Travel arrangements.
Dinner reservations.
Hotel confirmations.
Photographs.
Promises.
He scrolled back to a message sent seven months earlier.
Olivia had written:
Once the European deal closes, everything will be easier. You won't have to pretend anymore, and I'll finally have the place in your life you promised me.
Richard had replied:
Let's get through the acquisition first. I will handle everything afterward.
He stared at the message.
The sentence seemed to summarize the entire disaster.
Later.
He would attend the next appointment later.
He would explain the relationship later.
He would become a father later.
He would answer the hospital later.
He had treated the future as a storage room for every responsibility he did not want to face.
Now the future had arrived, and Maya had left him outside the door.
His phone rang again.
This time, it was Eleanor.
He answered immediately.
"Where is she?"
Eleanor's voice was tired.
"Richard, I told you—"
"I need to see my children."
"Then speak to Margaret Ellis. She is handling the legal arrangements."
"I am their father."
"That is not a magic phrase that makes everything else disappear."
He stood.
"Mom, I am trying to fix this."
"No. You are trying to regain control of it."
"I made a mistake."
"You made a series of choices. A mistake is what happens when you reach for salt and pick up sugar. You knew where you were. You knew who was calling. You knew your wife was pregnant."
Richard's throat tightened.
"What do you want me to do?"
"Start by telling the truth."
"About what?"
"Everything."
He said nothing.
Eleanor continued.
"Tell your wife the truth about Olivia. Tell your company the truth about your absences if they ask. Tell yourself the truth about why you ignored those calls."
"Are you saying I should resign?"
"I'm saying that you should stop believing that every problem can be solved by keeping your position."
He closed his eyes.
"Can I speak to Maya?"
"No."
"Please."
"She is recovering from surgery. She is feeding three newborns. She is learning how to sleep in short intervals and trying to heal from an experience that frightened her more than you understand."
"I just want to apologize."
"Then write the apology. Do not demand that she listen to it."
The call ended.
Richard sat down again.
For the first time in his adult life, he was forced to confront a situation in which he could not use authority to accelerate the outcome.
He could not order Maya to return.
He could not make Eleanor tell him where she was.
He could not persuade a judge to erase the past.
And he could not make the hospital's records disappear.
He looked at the photograph of Olivia on his phone.
Then he deleted it.
Not because deleting a photograph changed anything.
Because, for once, he needed to make a decision that did not depend on being watched.
He opened a blank document and began writing.
Maya,
I know I have no right to ask you to forgive me.
He stopped.
The sentence looked too polished.
He deleted it.
Maya,
I ignored seventeen calls from the hospital while you were in emergency surgery because I chose to remain at Olivia's birthday celebration.
He stared at the words.
For several seconds, his hands hovered above the keyboard.
Then he continued.
I knew the calls were from the hospital. I knew you were close to delivering our children. I told myself that someone would contact me if the situation became serious, even though I had no evidence that anyone would be able to reach me after I turned off my phone.
I have no excuse for that decision.
He paused again.
The words were ugly.
They were also true.
He wrote until midnight.
He did not ask Maya to come home.
He did not ask her to withdraw the divorce petition.
He did not mention the gift he had bought.
When he finished, he sent the letter to Margaret Ellis with a request that she forward it only if Maya wished to receive it.
Then he closed his laptop.
For the first time since the babies were born, Richard had done something without expecting immediate forgiveness in return.
It was a small beginning.
May you like
It was not nearly enough.
And somewhere across Manhattan, Olivia Hart was preparing to make sure that his problems would become much larger.
Related Stories